The third category isdirectly addressed the killing or murdering act, i. This, according to robert louden, only serves to support the objection that virtue ethics is particularly weak in the. For example, having someone killed is not strictly killing him, but seems just the same morally speaking. Philippa foot, in her article euthanasia, takes issue with the argument that rachels offers in support of the claim that the actions of killing someone and of letting. But it is difficult to decide when death is better than life, perhaps because we see a conceptual connexion between life and good. Read this philosophy research paper and over 89,000 other research documents. Philippa foot was born philippa judith bosanquet on october 3, 1920, in owston ferry, lincolnshire, and grew up in kirkleatham, in north yorkshire, england. She defended the objectivity of moral judgment and took controversial positions on abortion and euthanasia. Philippa foot s moral thought john hackerwright philippa foot 19202010 is widely regarded as one of the most important anglophone moral philosophers of the 20th century. The problem of abortion and the doctrine of the double effect. One person is working on one branch, and five on the other, and the trolley will kill anyone working on the branch it enters.
Morality as a system of hypothetical imperatives by philippa foot. Moral distinctions between passive and active euthanasia. Foot stands out among contemporary ethical theorists because of her conviction that virtues and vices are more central ethical notions than rights, duties, justice, or consequencesthe primary focus of most other contemporary moral theoriststhese essays embody to some extent her commitment to. Foot s paper on euthanasia 1977 are among the few exceptions. I conclude that even if an act of euthanasia is an instance of killing, and there exists a. Assisted suicideds or euthanasia linkedin slideshare. Foot thinks this because she can see no basis for the claim that we always have a. Nonvoluntary active euthanasia always violates a right to noninterference, and nothing overrides this, so its always. But in her 1977 paper euthanasia philosophy and public affairs 62 philippa foot argues that rachels is mistaken and wrote james rachels believes that if the difference between active and passive is relevant anywhere, it should be relevant everywhere, and he has pointed to an example in which it seems to make no difference which is done. Analysis of philippa foots article on euthanasia essay. The nonvoluntary euthanasia is generally not acceptable and is illegal in all countriesaccepting extreme conditions for the infants in some of the countries. James rachels, active and passive euthanasia, new england journal of.
It is a curious fact that no one of the three gives an adequate definition of the word as it is usually understood. A more basic distinction is, she thinks, between initiating a harmful sequence of events and not interfering to prevent it. Pdf philippa foot virtues and vices and other essay. But even if a morally neutral ie nonquestion begging distinction could be drawn, its application to the euthanasia controversy is problematic. Her father, william was an industrialist, running a large yorkshire steel works.
James rachels and philippa foot, both philosophers, have explored the realm of euthanasia from different moral points of view. A runaway train or trolley comes to a branch in the track. By definition, euthanasia must be supposed to be a good to the person killed. Philippa ruth foot was born on 3 october 1920, the second daughter of. Philippa foot 19202010 is widely regarded as one of the most important anglophone moral philosophers of the 20th century. A problem in medical ethics is examined in this discussion of euthanasia, which starts with a rejection of use of the term by the nazis to describe their killing of unwanted mental patients. Foot, philippa hursthouse major reference works wiley. Philippa foot produced a slim output of articles, most of which are collected. Active and passive euthanasia, he states that neither active nor passive euthanasia are morally different from each other because the intent is the same for both. Analysis of philippa foot s article on euthanasia and other kinds of academic papers in our essays database at many essays. Peter singer 2002 canadian medical association journal 166 8. A critique of foot s solution to the problem is explored, and the lecture ends with judith jarvis thomsons proposed alternative. Exploring psychological meaning and attitudes in a sample of mexican physicians and medical students. Through philippa foot s article she is trying to show more content it would be hard to devise procedures that would protect people from being persuaded into giving their consent.
Inherrecent article euthanasia,3 philippa foot attempts to employ such a distinction in order to conclude that all instances of nonvoluntary active euthanasia are unjustified. Foot defines euthanasia as a killing that is for the good of the individual. The socalled trolley problem was first discussed by philippa foot in 1967 as a way to test moral intuitions regarding the doctrine of double effect, kantian principles and utilitarianism. Philippa foot 1977 philosophy and public affairs 6 2. She pioneered a distinctive approach to philosophical treatment of ethics. She pioneered a distinctive approach to philosophical treatment of ethics using the tools of analytic philosophy. In an attempt to delve into the moral permissibility of euthanasia, i will first go over some of the medical terms. This includes her remarkable paper euthanasia philosophy and public. I illustrate the difficulties of employing this distinction to reach moral conclusions by critically discussing philippa foot s recent treatment of euthanasia. Virtues and vices philippa foot oxford university press. Analysis of philippa foot s article on euthanasia essay 75 words 6 pages euthanasia as defined by the shorter oxford english dictionary is a quiet and easy death. But one person needs 5 times more than any of the others. Foot argues that, contrary to commonlyheld belief, moral judgments are not categorical imperatives, but rather are hypothetical imperatives like other judgments.
Philippa ruth foot 19202010 i philippa ruth foot was born on 3 october 1920, the second daughter of william bosanquet, who had done mathematics at cambridge and became the manager of a steelworks in yorkshire, and esther cleveland, daughter of president grover cleveland. About the trolley problem the trolley problem or the trolley dilemma is a thought experiment proposed by the british philosopher philippa foot in her paper entitled the problem of abortion and the doctrine of the double effect. Through philippa foot s article she is trying to prove that an act of euthanasia is morally permissible as long as you are doing that act for the right reasons. Analysis of philippa foots article on euthanasia case. Abstract philippa foot 19202010 is widely regarded as one of the. She was educated mainly at home in the country by governesses, and not. Philippa foot handles the question of when life is a good to the one whose life it is in terms of minimum human goods. Philippa foot, in her article euthanasia, takes issue with the argument that rachels offers in support of the claim that the. Analysis of philippa foots article on euthanasia 76. Philippa foot euthanasia the widely used shorter oxford english dictionary gives three mean ings for the word euthanasia. Philippa foot s moral thought download ebook pdf, epub. Euthanasia as defined by the shorter oxford english dictionary is a quiet and easy death.
Philippa foot euthanasia the widely used shorter oxford english dictionary gives three meanings for the word euthanasia. In the second part of the lecture, philippa foot s trolley problem is introduced, which poses the problem of reconciling two powerful conflicting moral intuitions. In this section i will argue that her reasoning in support ofthis conclusion is defective. Pdf on feb 1, 2009, francisco javier ansuategui roig and others. Matters of life and death handout 3b the value of life.
1384 3 404 619 1503 1015 1328 1217 402 884 393 1182 490 577 746 556 1058 853 1127 628 1137 1581 1390 441 604 1397 559 395 936 1217 677 1213 50 736 528 1185 1 1128